What Are The Odds
- Commish
- 4 days ago
- 14 min read
We’ve reached that moment when every owner suddenly remembers that the regular season does, in fact, end. Three weeks remain. Three. And in those three weeks, reputations will be salvaged, seasons will be torched, and at least one franchise will convince themselves they “controlled their own destiny” right up until the exact moment destiny punched them in the throat.
The playoff picture — if you squint hard enough — has begun to take shape. Some teams have already booked their ticket. Some are still clawing at the window. And a few are tapping politely at the emergency exit despite the flight being over.
Below, I’ve laid out the landscape as clearly as possible, though clarity has never been this league’s strong suit.
Cactus Conference
Who Is You (10–1)
Let’s begin with the one stable pillar in this collapsing canyon. Who Is You has already clinched the Cactus East and the playoffs, and unless they decide to take the next three weeks off to pursue a more enriching hobby... birdwatching, pottery, rebuilding the Roman Empire. There’s almost no scenario where they don’t finish as the conference’s top seed.
A single win locks it. A single Fat Cats or Consolation Kings loss almost locks it. Their PF lead might as well be a moat.
There is nothing left to analyze except how smug they will be when they arrive.
Fat Cats (7-4)
The Fat Cats sit at 7–4 and, barring a catastrophic identity crisis, are cruising toward a playoff berth. Two wins in the final three weeks would slam the door shut, but even a single victory likely does the trick as long as Consolation Kings stumble once or the usual suspects — Uncle Bucky and Pork Chop Express — do their part and trip over their own shoelaces. And truthfully, even if the Cats decide to go sightseeing for the rest of the month and drop all three games, they’re still not dead unless Bucky and the Chops both suddenly play competent football and Los Perros Locos remembers how to win three straight. I wouldn’t bet my lunch on that happening.
As for the division title, the math is simple: finish ahead of the Kings or tie them and let the tiebreaker do the heavy lifting. With a nearly 90-point cushion (1183 to 1096), the Cats are in no danger of losing that one unless they stop scoring entirely. In short, Fat Cats are sitting pretty... an 85–90% playoff lock and about a 60% favorite to claim the Cactus West, assuming they don’t forget how to be a functioning franchise in the meantime.
Consolation Kings (7-4)
The Kings look every bit the playoff team their record suggests... at least until you glance at their Total Points Scored and realize they’re doing it with far less horsepower than Fat Cats. Their path is mostly identical to their feline counterparts: win two of their last three and they’re safely in, win just one and they only need a little help from Uncle Bucky or Pork Chop Express stumbling over themselves. Even a 7–7 finish might be survivable thanks to the tie-breaker advantage over some of the other bubble dwellers, though relying on that is the fantasy equivalent of using duct tape as structural support.
Winning the division, however, is another story. The Kings either need to finish ahead of Fat Cats outright or somehow erase an 87-point deficit in the final weeks... an outcome about as likely as Deez Nuts suddenly running the table. Their elimination scenario requires a perfect storm of bad luck, hot streaks from Uncle Bucky, Pork Chop Express, and Los Perros Locos, and their own 0–3 collapse… all highly unlikely unless they’re truly committed to chaos. In the end, they’re sitting with an 80–90% playoff chance but only about a 25% shot at taking the division, and the tie-breaker is the anchor holding them back.
Uncle Bucky (6-5)
With 6 wins, Bucky sits smack in the middle of the Wild Card melee and staring down a remaining schedule that reads less like a path and more like a punishment. Three straight conference games — Who Is You, Consolation Kings, and Los Perros Locos — form a gauntlet that would make sturdier teams queasy. Still, the math isn’t unfriendly: go 2–1 and they’re practically in, go 1–2 and they just need Pork Chop Express to stumble and Los Perros Locos to remember who they really are. Their scoring advantage gives them tiebreaker insurance over most of the bubble pack, which is the closest thing to comfort they’re likely to experience.
Of course, Bucky being Bucky, there’s always the nightmare scenario: lose out and they’re toast, or go 1–2 and watch the Chops, Perros, and even Baby Got Dak get their acts together at the same time... a sequence of events so statistically bizarre it would require the league to collectively abandon its core identity of incompetence. Realistically, they’re sitting around a 55–60% playoff chance, entirely beholden to a schedule that seems designed to expose their flaws. If they want in, they’ll have to earn it the hard way… which has never been their preferred method.
Pork Chop Express (6-5)
Pork Chop Express sits waist-deep — no, neck-deep — in the Wild Card scramble, desperately trying to keep their head above water while half the conference dog-paddles around them. Their path is straightforward in theory: win two of their last three and they’re basically in. Anything short of that requires help, and not the dignified kind. Uncle Bucky needs to drop a couple, Los Perros Locos must remember they’re allergic to winning streaks, and Baby Got Dak has to stay committed to mediocrity. The real problem is Pork Chop’s scoring, a meager 1033 points on the season that gives them less tiebreaker leverage than a coupon that expired three months ago.
Their elimination paths aren’t subtle: lose Weeks 12 and 13 and they almost certainly fall behind Bucky and Perros, and dropping Week 14 to Consolation Kings would slam the coffin shut. They have a path, but it’s built on stilts sinking into soft sand. At roughly a 55% playoff chance, the Chops are alive, but only because the rest of the conference refuses to enforce basic standards of competence. They need wins, not wishful thinking, to finish this out.
Los Perros Locos (5-6)
The Perros are technically alive but walking a tightrope over a pit of their own bad decisions. Their remaining schedule is the stuff of anxiety dreams: at Baby Got Dak, then Who Is You, then at Uncle Bucky. It’s a run of games that would make even stable franchises sweat, and the dogs have never been accused of stability. Still, their scoring is strong enough to keep hope breathing; at 1169 total points, they can win tiebreakers against most of the other bubble teams without breaking a sweat, which is good because they won’t have the luxury of breaking anything else.
Their path is simple and cruel. Go 2–1 and pray Bucky stumbles, Pork Chop hiccups, and Baby Got Dak stays true to form. Go 3–0 and the world opens up, but that requires beating Who Is You in Week 13, an experience most teams describe as “educational” in the most painful sense. One loss in Week 12 makes the 3–0 dream a fever fantasy. A Week 13 loss makes Week 14 a full-blown elimination game in enemy territory. They hold about a 35–40% playoff chance, powered entirely by their scoring and strangled by schedule. They’re alive, but living dangerously tends to end the same way in this conference.
Baby Got Dak (5-6)
Suggesting Dak is “alive” here feels a bit generous. They're more like a houseplant that hasn’t been watered in three weeks but somehow hasn’t fully wilted. They need to win at least two of their final three games just to enter the conversation, and even then they’ll require Uncle Bucky, Pork Chop Express, and Los Perros Locos to all politely step aside and lose at coordinated intervals. That’s not a path — it’s a hostage negotiation with the universe. Worse still, their total scoring sits at a limp 1061, meaning any 7–7 ties will treat them like the unwanted cousin at Thanksgiving.
The pitfalls are obvious. Lose to Los Perros Locos in Week 12 and the path shrinks to a sliver. Lose to Fat Cats in Week 14 and the season ends with a whimper, not a bang. Realistically, Baby Got Dak is operating with about a 22–25% playoff chance, and that figure may be inflated by optimism alone. They need wins, they need help, and they need several other teams to make worse decisions than they usually do... a challenging request in the chaos-ridden Cactus Conference.
Sagebrush Conference
Badazz Bri (8-3)
At 8–3, Bri has all but punched their postseason ticket with the subtlety of a marching band. They are, barring a miracle, locked into the playoff field; the only drama left is whether they stroll in as the Sagebrush Conference’s top seed or merely settle for second. One more win probably gets them the #1 seed, and even that might be generous — Gotham dropping a game would hand it to them outright. Their scoring may be lighter than it should be for a team with this record, but when you win this much, the math stops asking questions.
There is theoretically a danger zone, but only in the same way meteor strikes are technically possible. Bri would need to lose one more than the Rogues down the stretch, and only then would the tie-breaker even come into play. It’s not impossible... it’s just the kind of scenario no one should bother budgeting emotional energy for. At this point, Bri is 99.99% in and about a 90% favorite for the top seed. The only real mystery left is how they plan to squander this advantage once the playoffs begin.
Cerebral Ballsy (6-5)
With 6 wins, Cerebral Ballsy is technically leading the Sagebrush West, though “leading” here feels more like being the tallest person in a very short room. They are favored to win the division, but only because MaxxCasualties and Blue Ribbon have spent the season tripping over their own shoelaces. Win two of their last three and the division is theirs. Even one win probably keeps them afloat, assuming Casualties and Ribbon continue their tradition of mistaking momentum for a rumor.
The only real danger comes if Ballsy decides to enter a full three-week hibernation. A 0–3 collapse, combined with Casualties and Ribbon both going 2–1, would not only drop them out of the division lead but also shove them into a Wild Card fight they are absolutely not built to win. In that scenario, Gotham or even a stray Cactus team would gleefully kick them down the ladder. Realistically, though, Ballsy sits with a 70–80% chance to win the division and an 80–90% chance to make the playoffs. It’s not security — they don’t deserve that word — but it’s close enough for their division.
Gotham Rogues (7-4)
The Rogues sit at 7–4 and carry themselves like a team that already has one hand on a playoff ticket and the other casually checking their watch. They’re not officially in yet, but you can practically see the outline of their name on the Wild Card bracket. One win in the final three weeks should punch their ticket. Two wins might even put pressure on Badazz Bri if the East somehow gets spicy down the stretch. And should they stumble and lose all three? Their scoring cushion is large enough to catch them before they hit the rocks... 1060 points should be enough to fend off the Sagebrush West riffraff.
The only scenario that sends them spiraling involves a perfect storm of absurdity: the Rogues go 0–3, MaxxCasualties or Blue Ribbon suddenly remember how to be functional, and Golden Tate Warriors win out, all while the season scoring trend somehow flips. It’s the sort of cosmic chain reaction that would make astronomers uncomfortable. Realistically, Gotham holds a 90–95% chance of reaching the postseason. They’re not flashy, but they’re durable. And in this conference, durability is a luxury.
MaxxCasualties (5-6)
MaxxCasualties finds themselves in a familiar position: standing in the middle of the Sagebrush West crossroads, peering down multiple paths, and realizing that only one of them actually leads anywhere. At 5–6, their Wild Card dreams are already chalk outlines — too many teams in the East have racked up seven wins for Maxx to sneak in through the side door. Their most viable route is to win the division outright, which means outpacing both Cerebral Ballsy and Blue Ribbon over the final stretch.
A perfect 3–0 finish would almost certainly hand them the West, if only because no one else in the division appears interested in holding it. A 2–1 record keeps them alive, but only if Ballsy stumbles twice or Ribbon obliges with at least one faceplant. Anything less than that — 1–2 or the dreaded 0–3 — and the lights go out on their postseason hopes. At this point, MaxxCasualties carries roughly a 30–35% chance of slipping into the playoffs. Not impossible, but they’re trying to thread a needle using hands that have never once demonstrated fine motor control.
Blue Ribbon (5-6)
Blue Ribbon has somehow managed to recreate MaxxCasualties’ predicament but with even less margin for error and considerably worse aesthetics. In all likelihood, their only road into the postseason runs straight through the Sagebrush West division title, which is a bit like saying their only route to safety is crossing a bridge that may or may not be load-bearing. A 3–0 finish puts them firmly in the conversation, and a 2–1 stretch could work if Cerebral Ballsy obliges with a full-blown collapse. Anything short of that and they can start preparing their polite “we’ll get ’em next year” statements.
The real anchor on this operation is their ability to score. At just 1032 points this season, it’s the weakest total among the West contenders and makes every potential tiebreaker a losing battle before it even starts. That disadvantage haunts both their Wild Card fantasies — which were never realistic — and their division ambitions. As it stands, Blue Ribbon carries about a 25–30% chance of pulling this off, and that number is only that high because the rest of the division keeps leaving the door unlocked.
Tallahassee Tator Tots (4-7)
Tallahassee Tator Tots are technically still alive, though at this point their playoff hopes have the same energy as a flashlight on 1% battery. There is exactly one path for them, and it is the fantasy-football equivalent of assembling IKEA furniture while blindfolded in the back of a moving car. They must win out — an ambitious premise on its own — and then they need Cerebral Ballsy to forget how football works for three straight weeks, MaxxCasualties to slip on at least two metaphorical banana peels, and Blue Ribbon to faithfully continue being Blue Ribbon. After all that, Tallahassee would still need to somehow win a tiebreaker despite carrying a total barely higher than a strong breeze.
What knocks them out? A loss. Any loss. A poor quarter. A questionable coaching decision. A bad vibe. The Tots are operating with less than a 5% chance, and even that number assumes the universe has a sense of humor. They’re alive only in the strictest mathematical sense and only because the SCL Rule Book refuses to enforce a minimum standard of competence.
Golden Tate Warriors (4-7)
The Golden Tate Warriors are clinging to playoff hope with the sort of optimism usually found in late-night infomercials. Their path isn’t just narrow, it’s practically theoretical. They can’t catch Badazz Bri or Gotham Rogues for a Wild Card, so their only lifeline is winning out and praying for a symphony of collapses across the Sagebrush West: Cerebral Ballsy must drop all three, MaxxCasualties and Blue Ribbon both need to go 1–2, and Tallahassee Tator Tots must lose exactly once — which makes their Week 14 showdown an elimination game featuring two teams that probably shouldn’t need the term explained. And lurking beneath it all is the Warriors' scoring total of 910 points, the lowest among all bubble teams and roughly the equivalent of a polite shrug.
As for what ends their season? Take your pick. A single loss will do it. One Ballsy win will do it. Two wins by either MaxxCasualties or Blue Ribbon will definitely do it. At an estimated 1–2% playoff chance, the Warriors' postseason dream is less “long shot” and more “fiction.” If they make it to the postseason, it will be because the universe briefly malfunctioned and forgot how probability works.
Rounding out the league, there's no analysis to give for Deez Nuts and Do Not Panic because their seasons have already been embalmed and filed away. The Nuts secured their elimination weeks ago with a level of consistency you almost have to admire, while Panic followed closely behind, proving once again that determination alone cannot overcome a talent deficit of that magnitude. There’s nothing left for either team but the role of spoiler, chaos agent, or comic relief... roles they’ve been preparing for all season whether they knew it or not.
And now, with three games left, everyone else has a choice: sharpen up or get swallowed by the standings. This is the stretch where contenders steady themselves and pretenders hope no one notices the wobble in their step. I won’t pretend I expect greatness from all of you — not after what I’ve seen these past eleven weeks — but I will say this: there’s still time to surprise me. Or disappoint me in new, inventive ways. Either outcome would be perfectly on brand for this league. Now go finish your seasons with whatever dignity you can scrounge up.
Good luck in the final weeks!
Commish
Golden Ticket
The Golden Ticket standings are starting to look like a class photo where only a few students remembered picture day. Fat Cats sits miles ahead of everyone at 1,722 points, flexing a roster that somehow avoids the weekly chaos that swallows the rest of this league. Who Is You trails respectably, followed by Cerebral Ballsy and Golden Tate Warriors... teams that chose well enough to stay above the noise, though not well enough to silence it.
Then the mediocrity parade begins. MaxxCasualties, Uncle Bucky, and Consolation Kings hover awkwardly in the middle like they misplaced the “elite” section of their roster. Below them sits a collection of rosters that defy explanation: Pork Chop Express treading water, Blue Ribbon drifting aimlessly, and Badazz Bri living proof that regular-season success does not translate to Golden Ticket competence. And anchoring the entire operation is Baby Got Dak at 1,110 points... so far behind the pack that even Deez Nuts looks like a model of consistency by comparison. If Fat Cats is the honor roll, Dak is the kid who proudly turned in a blank worksheet.
Pigskin Pick'Em
Much to everyone’s confusion, Baby Got Dak sits comfortably in first place at 114 wins. Either they’ve cracked the code on NFL unpredictability or they’re enjoying a lucky streak loud enough to irritate the rest of the field. Cerebral Ballsy lurks within striking distance, but the real congestion is the six-team pileup sitting just behind them, where no one seems particularly interested in separating from the pack.
The biggest movers are Los Perros Locos, climbing three spots into relevance, and Badazz Bri, who managed an impressive nine-spot swan dive straight out of contention. At the bottom, Consolation Kings continue to treat Pick’Em like a performance art piece, and Gotham Rogues remain stubbornly committed to picking games as if guided by lunar phases. With six weeks left, the contest remains open. But unless someone wakes up soon, Baby Got Dak is going to jog to the finish line uncontested.
Survivor Challenge
And then there were two. MaxxCasualties bowed out in Week 11 with a 74-point faceplant, clearing the stage for our final showdown between Uncle Bucky and Who Is You. Immunity is gone — no shields, no safety nets, just three weeks of head-to-head scoring where the first team to win twice walks away with the Survivor crown. Simple, brutal, and guaranteed to leave one team psychologically bruised.
Power Rankings
Week 11 didn’t do much to shuffle the throne: Who Is You remains the league’s top power with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer, and Uncle Bucky stays right on their heels after another solid showing. Fat Cats made the biggest splash among contenders, blasting Gotham Rogues into orbit with a 129–59 beatdown and climbing back into the top three like nothing ever happened. Meanwhile, MaxxCasualties took a swan dive after their 74-point catastrophe, and Cerebral Ballsy’s 139–68 implosion at the hands of Los Perros Locos pushed them down two spots in the rankings.
The Perros were the week’s big climbers, jumping three spots after their blowout win and reminding the league that power rankings value actual scoring, not good intentions. Meanwhile Badazz Bri, Blue Ribbon, and Tallahassee Tator Tots continue their slow drift toward the basement — each one determined to reach mediocrity on their own stylistic terms. And speaking of the basement, Consolation Kings, Do Not Panic, and Deez Nuts maintain their usual positions near the earth’s crust, offering the rest of the league a comforting layer of separation from true disgrace.
What If
If you’re brave enough to confront reality, the What If matrix is waiting to ruin your afternoon. You’ll notice Badazz Bri’s schedule is softer than a decorative pillow, with Blue Ribbon and Consolation Kings not far behind, while MaxxCasualties somehow pulled the fantasy equivalent of a prison sentence. Pork Chop Express and Baby Got Dak also drew some short straws, which should make a few teams feel better about where they sit. Take a look at your own team if you dare; nothing reveals the truth about your season faster than seeing what your record should have been.
Comments